What factors indicate an experimental purpose in patent law?
The MPEP outlines several factors that courts consider in determining whether a claimed invention was offered for sale primarily for experimental purposes:
- Necessity for public testing
- Inventor’s control over the experiment
- Nature of the invention
- Length of the test period
- Whether payment was made
- Presence of a secrecy obligation
- Record-keeping of the experiment
- Who conducted the experiment
- Degree of commercial exploitation during testing
- Whether the invention requires evaluation under actual conditions of use
- Systematic performance of testing
- Continuous monitoring by the inventor
- Nature of contacts with potential customers
As stated in the MPEP, “Another critical attribute of experimentation is the ‘customer’s awareness of the purported testing in the context of a sale.'” (MPEP 2133.03(e)(4))
To learn more:
Topics:
MPEP 2100 - Patentability,
MPEP 2133.03(E) - Permitted Activity; Experimental Use,
Patent Law,
Patent Procedure