How can an applicant overcome a restriction requirement between a product and its process of making or using?

An applicant can overcome a restriction requirement between a product and its process of making or using in several ways: Traverse the requirement: Argue that the restriction is improper by showing that the product cannot be made by a materially different process or used in a materially different way. Amend the claims: Modify the claims…

Read More

What is MPEP 821.04 and how does it relate to rejoinder of claims?

MPEP 821.04 is a section of the Manual of Patent Examining Procedure that provides detailed guidance on the rejoinder of claims. The MPEP 1302.04(h) specifically references this section: “See MPEP § 821.04.” MPEP 821.04 covers various aspects of rejoinder, including: Conditions for rejoinder of non-elected inventions Rejoinder of process claims Rejoinder of product claims Procedures…

Read More

What is the “Linking Claim” requirement for rejoinder?

A “linking claim” is a key requirement for rejoinder in patent applications. According to MPEP 821.04: “Where applicant elects claims directed to the product, and the product claims are subsequently found allowable, withdrawn process claims that depend from or otherwise require all the limitations of the allowable product claim will be considered for rejoinder.” This…

Read More

What are the key considerations for patent attorneys when drafting apparatus and product claims?

When drafting apparatus and product claims, patent attorneys should consider the following key points to navigate potential restriction requirements: Clearly differentiate between apparatus and product claims Consider the relationship between the apparatus and the product it produces Draft claims that highlight the unique features of both the apparatus and the product Be prepared to argue…

Read More

What are the form paragraphs used in restriction requirements for product and process of using?

The MPEP 806.05(h) specifies that form paragraphs 8.20 and 8.21.04 should be used in restriction requirements between the product and method of using. These form paragraphs serve specific purposes: Form Paragraph 8.20: Used to explain the relationship between product and process of use inventions and to state the reasons for distinctness. Form Paragraph 8.21.04: Provides…

Read More