What role do foreign classifications play in USPTO patent searches?
Foreign classifications play an important role in USPTO patent searches by expanding the scope of the search to include relevant prior art from other countries. According to MPEP 904.02(a): “A proper field of search normally includes the subclass in which the claimed subject matter of an application would be classified in the U.S. Patent Classification…
Read MoreWhat information is included in the examiner’s reasons for allowance?
What information is included in the examiner’s reasons for allowance? The examiner’s reasons for allowance are an important part of the Notice of Allowability. They typically include: A statement of the specific reason(s) why the claimed invention is allowable References to the closest prior art and how the claimed invention differs An explanation of any…
Read MoreWhat happens if an examiner discovers prior art after a notice of allowance?
If an examiner discovers prior art after a notice of allowance has been mailed, they may initiate a rejection process. According to MPEP 1308.01: “If the examiner discovers prior art after allowance that meets the requirements for rejections based on prior art, the examiner should first consider whether the reference(s) was cited in an Information…
Read MoreWhat are equivalents in patent examination?
In patent examination, equivalents refer to subject matter that is functionally equivalent to what is defined in a patent claim, even if it differs in form or structure. According to MPEP 904.01(b): “All subject matter that is the equivalent of the subject matter as defined in the claim, even though different from the definition in…
Read MoreHow is the effective filing date determined for prior art purposes?
The effective filing date for prior art purposes is generally the earliest filing date to which the application is entitled. This can include provisional applications, foreign priority applications, and earlier-filed U.S. applications, provided they adequately support the claimed invention. The MPEP notes: In determining the pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(e) date, consider benefit claims to earlier-filed…
Read MoreWhat is the effective date for claims in a reissue application?
Claims in a reissue application are treated as if they were presented in the original patent for the purpose of evaluating patentability over prior art. The MPEP 1440 states: “The claims in a reissue application are treated as if they were presented in the patent being reissued for purposes of evaluating patentability over prior art,…
Read MoreWhat is the effective date of an abandoned application as prior art?
The effective date of an abandoned application as prior art can vary: For published abandoned applications, the effective date is typically the publication date under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1). For unpublished abandoned applications referenced in other documents, the effective date is when the information became publicly available. The MPEP cites case law: “In re Heritage, 182…
Read MoreWhat is the effect of international publication on patent rights?
The international publication of a PCT application has several important effects on patent rights: It establishes provisional protection in designated States, similar to the effect of national publication of a national application. In the United States, it confers the right to reasonable royalty protection under 35 U.S.C. 154(d). The published application can serve as prior…
Read MoreWhat types of documents are included in the patent classification system?
According to MPEP 903.01, which cites 35 U.S.C. 8, the patent classification system includes: “United States letters patent, and such other patents and printed publications as may be necessary or practicable” This broad definition encompasses: U.S. patents Foreign patents Non-patent literature (printed publications) The inclusion of various document types ensures a comprehensive collection of prior…
Read MoreWhat types of documents related to abandoned applications can be used as prior art?
Various documents related to abandoned applications can serve as prior art: Patent application publications under 35 U.S.C. 122(b) Published abstracts Abbreviatures Defensive publications (see MPEP § 901.06(d)) Statutory invention registrations (see MPEP Chapter 1100) The MPEP explicitly states: “Published abstracts, abbreviatures, defensive publications (MPEP § 901.06(d)), and statutory invention registrations (MPEP Chapter 1100) are references.”…
Read More