How do patent examiners use the concept of combinations and subcombinations in their work?
Patent examiners use the concept of combinations and subcombinations in several aspects of their work: Evaluating claim scope and patentability Determining if a restriction requirement is necessary Assessing the relationship between different claims Applying prior art during examination The MPEP 806.05(a) provides the fundamental definition: “A combination is an organization of which a subcombination or…
Read MoreCan patent examiners use social media websites during Internet searches?
Patent examiners are allowed to visit social media websites that provide for public interactions as part of their Internet search. However, there are strict limitations on how they can interact with these platforms. The MPEP states: “As part of an Internet search, examiners may visit social media websites that provide for public interactions, but are…
Read MoreHow can patent examiners request materials not available in STIC?
Patent examiners can request materials not available in STIC through the Interlibrary Loan service. The process is as follows: Submit a request to the STIC facility in the examiner’s Technology Center (TC) Use the electronic form available on the STIC NPL website The MPEP 901.06(a) states: “When needed for official business purposes, STIC will borrow…
Read MoreCan examiners rely on machine translations of foreign language documents in patent examinations?
Yes, patent examiners can rely on machine translations of foreign language documents, but with certain conditions. According to MPEP 901.05(d): “Examiners may rely on a machine translation of a foreign language document unless the machine translation is not of sufficient quality to be adequate evidence of the contents of the document.” However, it’s important to…
Read MoreCan patent examiners rely on machine translations for non-English prior art?
Yes, patent examiners can rely on machine translations for non-English prior art, but with some caveats. The MPEP 901.05(d) states: “Examiners may rely on a machine translation of a foreign language document unless the machine translation is not of sufficient quality to be adequate evidence of the contents of the document.” Key points to note:…
Read MoreHow should patent examiners handle potentially copyrighted material during internet searches?
When conducting internet searches, patent examiners must be cautious about handling potentially copyrighted material. The MPEP 904.02(c) provides specific guidance on this matter: “Care should be taken to avoid copyright infringement when including an excerpt from a copyrighted source in an Office action. Usually, examiners should not include more than a limited number of paragraphs…
Read MoreWhat should be included in a patent examiner’s field of search?
A patent examiner’s field of search should be comprehensive and include various elements as outlined in MPEP 904.02(a): Classification locations where the claimed subject matter would be properly classified Every relevant group/subgroup of the Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC) Relevant class/subclass of the U.S. Patent Classification (USPC) Digests and cross-reference art collections Classifications assigned by foreign…
Read MoreHow do patent examiners determine if inventions are independent or distinct for restriction purposes?
Patent examiners determine if inventions are independent or distinct based on specific criteria outlined in the MPEP. According to MPEP 808, examiners must provide: “(A) the reasons (as distinguished from the mere statement of conclusion) why each invention as claimed is either independent or distinct from the other(s)“ To make this determination, examiners typically consider:…
Read MoreHow do patent examiners use Notes in CPC schemes?
Patent examiners rely heavily on Notes in CPC schemes to ensure accurate and consistent classification of patent applications. The MPEP 905.01(a)(2) provides insight into how Notes are structured: “Instruction in a ‘Note’ is applied only to the CPC place where it appears, including all its hierarchically lower places.” Patent examiners use Notes in several ways:…
Read MoreHow can patent examiners access non-patent literature through STIC?
Patent examiners can access non-patent literature through the Scientific and Technical Information Center (STIC) in several ways: Electronic Resources: STIC provides access to e-books, e-journals, and databases via the STIC NPL website. Print Collections: Each Electronic Information Center (EIC) has a tailored print collection for its Technology Center. Online Catalog: Examiners can use the STIC…
Read More