What is the process for rejecting previously allowed claims in patent examination?
The process for rejecting previously allowed claims involves the following steps: The examiner must obtain approval from the supervisory patent examiner (SPE) before rejecting a previously allowed claim. The examiner should clearly explain the reasons for the rejection in the Office action. The applicant must be given a non-final Office action with a new ground…
Read MoreWhat is the process for developing and approving new Form Paragraphs?
The process for developing and approving new Form Paragraphs is outlined in MPEP 707. While the specific details of ‘subsection I’ are not provided in the given excerpt, we can infer that there is a formal approval process in place. The MPEP states: “If the form paragraph does not require the specific change to the…
Read MoreWhat types of objective evidence are considered probative in patent examination?
Objective evidence that can be considered probative in patent examination includes: Unexpected results Commercial success Solution of a long-felt need Inoperability of the prior art Invention before the date of the reference Allegations of derivation of the disclosed subject matter from the inventor However, it’s important to note that “Objective evidence which must be factually…
Read MoreWhat should patent examiners do when they find patentable subject matter in a pro se application?
When a patent examiner finds patentable subject matter in a pro se application (filed by an inventor without legal representation), they should take proactive steps to assist the applicant. According to MPEP 707.07(j): When, during the examination of a pro se application it becomes apparent to the examiner that there is patentable subject matter disclosed…
Read MoreWhat types of information can an examiner request about prior art?
What types of information can an examiner request about prior art? An examiner can request various types of information about prior art, including: Copies of patents, publications, or other information products which the applicant has mentioned in the specification but has not submitted Names of persons skilled in the art who have made written opinions…
Read MoreWhat is the primary goal of patent examination?
The primary goal of patent examination is to thoroughly review and analyze the patent application in light of prior art and clearly articulate any rejections early in the prosecution process. As stated in the MPEP: “The goal of examination is to clearly articulate any rejection early in the prosecution process so that the applicant has…
Read MoreWhat is the role of a primary examiner in rejecting previously allowed claims?
The primary examiner plays a crucial role in the process of rejecting previously allowed claims. According to MPEP 706.04: “An Office action rejecting a previously allowed claim must be signed by a primary examiner.” The primary examiner must consider all the facts before making such a rejection They are responsible for exercising great care in…
Read MoreWhat is the role of a primary examiner in reviewing a new assistant’s work?
The primary examiner plays a crucial role in reviewing the work of a new assistant examiner. According to MPEP 707.01, “it is the duty of the primary examiner to review the application thoroughly.” This involves: Listening to the assistant examiner’s explanation of the invention Discussing the most pertinent references found during the search Providing guidance…
Read MoreWho reviews the sufficiency of affidavits or declarations under 37 CFR 1.130?
The sufficiency of affidavits or declarations under 37 CFR 1.130 is reviewed and decided by a primary examiner. As stated in MPEP 717.01(e): The question of sufficiency of affidavits or declarations under 37 CFR 1.130 should be reviewed and decided by a primary examiner. This means that the primary examiner is responsible for evaluating whether…
Read MoreHow does a primary examiner guide a new assistant in applying prior art rejections?
A primary examiner plays a crucial role in guiding new assistant examiners on applying prior art rejections. According to MPEP 707.01: “If action on the merits is to be given and claims rejected, the primary examiner may indicate how the references are to be applied in any prior art rejection and explain the basis for…
Read More