Can new arguments be presented in a Pre-Appeal Brief Request?
Can new arguments be presented in a Pre-Appeal Brief Request? No, new arguments should not be presented in a Pre-Appeal Brief Request. The MPEP clearly states: “No new arguments or evidence may be included in the request.” (MPEP 1204.02) The purpose of the Pre-Appeal Brief Request is to review the existing record and arguments. Applicants…
Read MoreWhat is the process for addressing rejections in design patent applications?
The process for addressing rejections in design patent applications involves a dialogue between the examiner and the applicant. According to MPEP 1504: “If the examiner determines that the claim of the design patent application does not satisfy the statutory requirements, the examiner will set forth in detail, and may additionally summarize, the basis for all…
Read MoreWhat role does ‘long-felt need’ play in commercial success arguments for patents?
What role does ‘long-felt need’ play in commercial success arguments for patents? ‘Long-felt need’ is a significant factor in commercial success arguments for patents. It demonstrates that the invention solves a problem that has existed in the industry for an extended period. The MPEP 716.04 states: Establishing long-felt need requires objective evidence that an art…
Read MoreHow do licensing activities support commercial success claims in patent cases?
How do licensing activities support commercial success claims in patent cases? Licensing activities can provide strong support for commercial success claims in patent cases. The MPEP 716.03(b)(II) addresses this: Licensing activities showing acceptance by others may be used to demonstrate commercial success if there was licensing of the invention by others during the period attributable…
Read MoreWhat is the importance of ‘nexus’ in commercial success arguments for patents?
What is the importance of ‘nexus’ in commercial success arguments for patents? ‘Nexus’ is crucial in commercial success arguments for patents as it establishes a direct link between the claimed invention and its market success. The MPEP 716.03 states: The term ‘nexus’ designates a factually and legally sufficient connection between the evidence of commercial success…
Read MoreHow does commercial success factor into long-felt need arguments for patents?
Commercial success can be a significant factor in supporting long-felt need arguments for patents. The MPEP 716.04 addresses this relationship: ‘Evidence of long-felt need may be shown by establishing a long-felt want or demand for a solution to a problem that has existed for a considerable length of time without solution by another.’ Commercial success…
Read More