How should an applicant respond to an Office Action?

When responding to an Office Action, applicants should: Include the application number, 4-digit art unit number, and examiner’s name Include the 4-digit confirmation number on every paper filed Address all rejections and objections raised in the Office Action Provide arguments for allowability as required by 37 CFR 1.111 The MPEP section 707 states: Replies to…

Read More

How should an examiner handle persuasive arguments from an applicant?

When an examiner finds an applicant’s arguments persuasive, they should take appropriate action. According to MPEP 707.07(f): If applicant’s arguments are persuasive and upon reconsideration of the rejection, the examiner determines that the previous rejection should be withdrawn, the examiner must provide in the next Office communication the reasons why the previous rejection is withdrawn…

Read More

What constitutes a fully responsive reply to a non-final Office action?

A fully responsive reply to a non-final Office action must address all objections and rejections raised by the examiner. According to MPEP 714.02: ‘The reply must present arguments pointing out the specific distinctions believed to render the claims, including any newly presented claims, patentable over any applied references.’ This means that applicants should: Respond to…

Read More

What is the examiner’s responsibility when applicant traverses a rejection?

When an applicant traverses a rejection, the examiner has a responsibility to address the applicant’s arguments. As stated in MPEP 707.07(f): Where the applicant traverses any rejection, the examiner should, if they repeat the rejection, take note of the applicant’s argument and answer the substance of it. This means the examiner must carefully consider the…

Read More

How should an examiner respond to applicant’s arguments in patent prosecution?

According to MPEP 707.07(f), examiners should respond to applicant’s arguments as follows: If repeating a rejection, take note of the applicant’s argument and answer the substance of it. If withdrawing a rejection due to persuasive arguments, provide reasons for the withdrawal by referring specifically to the applicant’s remarks. If making a new ground of rejection…

Read More