When can an examiner not require restriction between species in a patent application?

An examiner cannot require restriction between species in a patent application under certain circumstances. The MPEP 808.01(a) provides guidance on this: “In applications where only generic claims are presented, restriction cannot be required unless the generic claims recite or encompass such a multiplicity of species that an unduly extensive and burdensome search would be necessary…

Read More

What is a traverse in patent law?

In patent law, a traverse is a formal objection or disagreement with a requirement or decision made by the patent examiner. Specifically, in the context of restriction requirements, a traverse is a response where the applicant distinctly and specifically points out supposed errors in the restriction requirement. This is crucial because, as stated in MPEP…

Read More

What is the “decision tree” process mentioned in MPEP 904.02(b)?

The MPEP 904.02(b) mentions a “decision tree” process as a general methodology for making broad decisions in search tool selection. Specifically, it states: a general methodology following a “decision tree” process, set forth below, for making broad decisions in search tool selection is suggested. While the MPEP doesn’t provide the detailed decision tree in this…

Read More

How does the USPTO define a combination in patent applications?

The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) defines a combination in patent applications according to the Manual of Patent Examining Procedure (MPEP) 806.05(a). The MPEP states: “A combination is an organization of which a subcombination or element is a part.” This definition emphasizes that a combination in a patent application refers to a larger…

Read More

What is the balance between general and specific guidance for search tool selection in patent examination?

The USPTO maintains a balance between providing general guidance and allowing for specific, technology-focused approaches in search tool selection for patent examination. This balance is evident in MPEP 904.02(b), which states: Detailed guidance on the choice and use of specific search tools can be established only within the context of the special requirements of each…

Read More