TwitterLinkedinSkypeRssEmail
+1.970.776.4355
BlueIron IP
  • About
  • Services
    • Patent Financing by BlueIron
    • IP Insurance by BlueIron
    • Loans Using Patents As Collateral
  • Blog
  • All FAQs
    • Patent Financing
    • Patent Loans
    • Patent Insurance
    • Patent Law FAQ
  • Contact
  • Schedule a Call

Why is the Old Combination rejection no longer valid in patent examination?

By russ.krajec@blueironip.com | September 30, 2024

The Old Combination rejection is no longer valid due to changes in patent law and subsequent court interpretations. The MPEP 2173.05(j) states: “A majority opinion of the Board of Appeals held that Congress removed the underlying rationale of Lincoln Engineering in the 1952 Patent Act, and thereby effectively legislated that decision out of existence. Ex…

Read More

What is the “Old Combination” principle in patent law?

By russ.krajec@blueironip.com | September 30, 2024

The “Old Combination” principle was a former doctrine in patent law that suggested an inventor who improved only one element of an old combination should not be able to patent the entire combination. However, this principle is no longer valid in modern patent law. As stated in MPEP 2173.05(j): “A CLAIM SHOULD NOT BE REJECTED…

Read More

What was the Lincoln Engineering case and its impact on patent law?

By russ.krajec@blueironip.com | September 30, 2024

The Lincoln Engineering case (Lincoln Engineering Co. v. Stewart-Warner Corp., 303 U.S. 545, 37 USPQ 1 (1938)) was a significant ruling that established the Old Combination principle. According to MPEP 2173.05(j): “The principle was that an inventor who made an improvement or contribution to but one element of a generally old combination, should not be…

Read More

Search

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Bad Behavior By Angel Groups -“Due Diligence”
  • Gullible Angel Investors and Provisional Patent Applications
  • The Provisional Patent Hoax
  • How accelerators and angel groups lose their way.
  • The Endless Science Project
  • Calling yourself an “Expert”
  • Patents Age Like Fine Wine

Sign Me Up

Get weekly updates

This post was tagged

Angel Investing Attorney Client Relationship best mode description claims Design Patents Entrepreneurship Foreign Patents How To Get A Patent How To Patent An Idea Intellectual Property Intellectual Property Strategies Invent invention description Invest in Startups Investment Grade Patents Investor Due Diligence IP Due Diligence long descriptions Non Disclosure Agreement Patent Attorney patent attorneys patent claims Patent Cost Patent Drafting Patent Enforcement Patent Financing Patent Insurance Patent Law Firms Patent Licensing Patent Litigation Patent Portfolio Patent Prosecution Patent Protection patent specification Patent Value problems with patents Provisional Patent provisional patent applications provisional patents provisionals Seed Capital Tech Startups Trade Secret Utility Patents Why Get A Patent
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Media Kit
BlueIron IP | 1635 Foxtrail Drive, Ste 321 | Loveland, Colorado 80538 | USA