How does the principle of claim differentiation affect claim interpretation?
The principle of claim differentiation is an important tool in claim interpretation. According to the MPEP: “The presence of a dependent claim that adds a particular limitation raises a presumption that the limitation in question is not found in the independent claim.” This principle is based on the assumption that each claim in a patent…
Read MoreCan dependent claims be rewritten as independent claims after filing an appeal brief?
Yes, rewriting dependent claims into independent form is one of the few types of amendments that may be admitted after filing an appeal brief. According to MPEP 1206: “Amendments filed on or after the date of filing a brief pursuant to 37 CFR 41.37 and within the time period set forth in 37 CFR 90.3…
Read MoreHow should dependent claims be formatted in a PCT application?
Dependent claims in a PCT application should be formatted according to PCT Rule 6.4, as referenced in MPEP 1824: Dependent claims should refer to other claim(s) at the beginning They should state the additional features claimed Multiple dependent claims should refer to other claims in the alternative only Multiple dependent claims cannot serve as a…
Read MoreWhat happens when the Board affirms the examiner’s rejection but reverses rejections on dependent claims?
When the Board affirms a rejection against independent claims but reverses all rejections against dependent claims, the examiner has two options after the period for further appeal expires: Convert the dependent claims into independent form by examiner’s amendment, cancel all claims with affirmed rejections, and issue the application. Set a 2-month time limit for the…
Read MoreWhat types of amendments may be remanded for consideration during an appeal?
According to MPEP 1211.02, certain types of amendments may be remanded for consideration by the examiner during an appeal. Specifically: “[A] proposed amendment filed after the date of filing of a brief to either cancel claims, where such cancellation does not affect the scope of any other pending claim in the proceeding, or to rewrite…
Read MoreWhat are the thresholds for excess claims fees in patent applications?
The thresholds for excess claims fees in patent applications are set by the USPTO. According to MPEP 714.10: Applicant is required to pay excess claims fees for each claim that is in excess of 3 in independent form or in excess of 20 (whether dependent or independent). This means that: You can have up to…
Read MoreWhat are excess claims fees in patent applications?
Excess claims fees are charges that applicants must pay for claims that exceed certain thresholds in a patent application. According to MPEP 714.10: Applicant is required to pay excess claims fees for each claim that is in excess of 3 in independent form or in excess of 20 (whether dependent or independent). These fees are…
Read MoreHow should a dependent claim be written to properly incorporate limitations from its parent claim?
How should a dependent claim be written to properly incorporate limitations from its parent claim? To properly incorporate limitations from a parent claim, a dependent claim should be written following these guidelines: Reference the parent claim: Begin the dependent claim by referring to the parent claim by number (e.g., “The device of claim 1, wherein…”).…
Read MoreHow should claim numbering be handled in patent applications?
Proper claim numbering is an important aspect of patent application review. MPEP 1302.01 provides guidance on this matter: The claims should be renumbered as required by 37 CFR 1.126, and particular attention should be given to claims dependent on previous claims to see that the numbering is consistent. This means that during the general review…
Read MoreHow should dependent claims be arranged in a patent application?
The arrangement of dependent claims in a patent application should follow specific guidelines as outlined in MPEP 608.01(n): A claim which depends from a dependent claim should not be separated from it by any claim which does not also depend from that dependent claim. A dependent claim may refer back to any preceding independent claim.…
Read More