How does the ‘teaching, suggestion, or motivation’ (TSM) test apply in obviousness determinations?
How does the ‘teaching, suggestion, or motivation’ (TSM) test apply in obviousness determinations? The ‘teaching, suggestion, or motivation’ (TSM) test is an important concept in determining obviousness in patent examination. According to MPEP 2143, while the TSM test is not the sole test for obviousness, it remains a valid approach: “The Supreme Court in KSR…
Read MoreWhat are the key requirements for establishing a prima facie case of obviousness?
The key requirements for establishing a prima facie case of obviousness are: Resolving the Graham factual inquiries Articulating a clear rationale for why the claimed invention would have been obvious Providing a reasoned explanation that avoids conclusory generalizations As stated in the MPEP: “The key to supporting any rejection under 35 U.S.C. 103 is the…
Read MoreWhat is the ‘reasonable expectation of success’ criterion in obviousness analysis?
What is the ‘reasonable expectation of success’ criterion in obviousness analysis? The ‘reasonable expectation of success’ is a crucial criterion in determining obviousness in patent examination. According to MPEP 2143, this concept is particularly important when considering whether a claimed invention would have been obvious to try. The MPEP states: “Obviousness can be established by…
Read MoreWhat are the key elements of the ‘obvious to try’ rationale in patent obviousness?
What are the key elements of the ‘obvious to try’ rationale in patent obviousness? The ‘obvious to try’ rationale is one of the exemplary rationales used to support a conclusion of obviousness in patent examination. According to MPEP 2143, the key elements of this rationale are: A finding that there had been a finite number…
Read MoreWhat is the “obvious to try” rationale for obviousness?
The “obvious to try” rationale for obviousness can be used when: There is a recognized problem or need in the art There are a finite number of identified, predictable potential solutions to the problem One of ordinary skill in the art could have pursued these potential solutions with a reasonable expectation of success As stated…
Read MoreHow does the ‘design choice’ rationale apply in obviousness rejections?
How does the ‘design choice’ rationale apply in obviousness rejections? The ‘design choice’ rationale is one of the exemplary rationales used to support a conclusion of obviousness in patent examination. According to MPEP 2143, this rationale can be applied when: “The claimed structure and the prior art structure are identical or substantially identical, or are…
Read MoreHow does common sense factor into obviousness determinations?
Common sense can be applied in obviousness determinations, but it must be supported by reasoned analysis and evidentiary support. Key points about using common sense include: It can inform the obviousness analysis if explained with sufficient reasoning A specific teaching or suggestion in a particular reference is not required Conclusory generalizations should be avoided As…
Read More