What are examples of universal facts that can be shown by non-prior art references?
Non-prior art references can be used to show universal facts in patent examination. The MPEP 2124 provides several examples of such universal facts: Characteristics and properties of a material Scientific truisms Whether undue experimentation would have been required at the filing date Whether a parameter was critical or not The accuracy of statements in the…
Read MoreWhat are “universal facts” in the context of MPEP 2124?
What are “universal facts” in the context of MPEP 2124? In the context of MPEP 2124, “universal facts” refer to information that is generally known or widely accepted in the field of the invention. These facts are considered to be so fundamental that they don’t require prior art status to be used in patent examination.…
Read MoreHow does the exception to the prior art rule affect patent litigation?
The exception to the prior art rule, as described in MPEP 2124, can have significant implications in patent litigation. This exception allows for the use of post-filing date evidence in certain circumstances, which can affect arguments related to enablement, written description, and the state of the art. For example, the Federal Circuit case Amgen Inc.…
Read MoreCan a reference published after the filing date be used under MPEP 2124?
Can a reference published after the filing date be used under MPEP 2124? Yes, under certain circumstances, a reference published after the filing date of an application can be used as described in MPEP 2124. However, its use is limited and specific. The MPEP states: “References which do not qualify as prior art because they…
Read MoreCan post-filing date evidence be used to determine enablement or written description?
No, post-filing date evidence cannot be used to determine enablement or written description under 35 U.S.C. 112(a). The MPEP 2124 clearly states: “It is impermissible to use a later factual reference showing the state of the art existing after the effective filing date of the application to determine whether the application is enabled or described…
Read MoreHow can a non-prior art reference be used under MPEP 2124?
How can a non-prior art reference be used under MPEP 2124? Under MPEP 2124, a non-prior art reference can be used in specific ways during patent examination: To show the level of ordinary skill in the art at the time of the invention To demonstrate that certain features were well-known in the art To provide…
Read MoreWhat is the purpose of MPEP 2124?
What is the purpose of MPEP 2124? MPEP 2124 outlines an important exception to the general rule that a reference must qualify as prior art to be used in rejecting claims. The purpose of this section is to explain when and how a reference that is not prior art can still be used to show…
Read MoreHow can later publications be used to show the level of ordinary skill in the art?
Later publications, which do not qualify as prior art due to their post-dating of the claimed invention, can still be valuable in patent examination. According to MPEP 2124: “References which do not qualify as prior art because they postdate the claimed invention may be relied upon to show the level of ordinary skill in the…
Read MoreWhen can later publications be used as references in patent examination?
Later publications can be used as references in patent examination under specific circumstances, primarily to show universal facts or scientific truisms. The MPEP 2124 provides several examples: To show that undue experimentation would have been required as of the filing date To demonstrate whether a parameter was critical or not To prove that a statement…
Read MoreWhat is the exception to the rule that a reference must be prior art?
The exception to the rule that a reference must be prior art allows for the use of later publications to show factual evidence in certain circumstances. As stated in MPEP 2124: “In certain circumstances, references cited to show a universal fact need not be available as prior art before applicant’s filing date.” These facts can…
Read More