What are examples of claims with self-evident eligibility?

The MPEP 2106.06(a) provides several examples of claims with self-evident eligibility:

  • Robotic arm assembly: “A robotic arm assembly having a control system that operates using certain mathematical relationships is clearly not an attempt to tie up use of the mathematical relationships and would not require a full analysis to determine eligibility.”
  • Artificial hip prosthesis: “A claim directed to an artificial hip prosthesis coated with a naturally occurring mineral is not an attempt to tie up the mineral.”
  • Products with ancillary nature-based components: “A claim that is directed to a cellphone with an electrical contact made of gold or a plastic chair with wood trim, would not require analysis of the nature-based component to determine whether the claims are directed to a ‘product of nature’ exception.”

These examples illustrate claims that do not attempt to monopolize judicial exceptions and thus qualify for streamlined eligibility analysis.

To learn more:

Topics: MPEP 2100 - Patentability, MPEP 2106.06(A) - Eligibility Is Self Evident, Patent Law, Patent Procedure
Tags: Judicial Exception, Patent Examples, Self-Evident Eligibility