How does the use of block diagrams in a patent application affect the enablement requirement?
The use of block diagrams in a patent application can be sufficient to meet the enablement requirement under certain conditions. According to MPEP 2185:
“Note that the description of an apparatus with block diagrams describing the function, but not the structure, of the apparatus is not fatal under the enablement requirement of 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, first paragraph, as long as the structure is conventional and can be determined without an undue amount of experimentation.”
This guidance suggests that block diagrams can be used to describe the function of an apparatus without necessarily detailing its structure, provided that:
- The structure is conventional in the field
- A person skilled in the art can determine the structure without undue experimentation
However, applicants should be cautious about relying solely on block diagrams, especially for novel or non-conventional structures, as this may not be sufficient to meet the enablement requirement in all cases.
To learn more: