How does the USPTO determine if inventions are “independent and distinct” for restriction purposes?
The concept of “independent and distinct” inventions is crucial for restriction practice, as mentioned in 35 U.S.C. 121. However, the MPEP section provided does not give specific criteria for this determination. Generally, the USPTO considers inventions to be independent when there is no disclosed relationship between them, and distinct when they have a materially different design, mode of operation, function, or effect, even though they may be related.
The determination is made on a case-by-case basis by patent examiners, who consider factors such as:
- The relationship between the inventions
- The classification of the inventions
- The search burden involved in examining multiple inventions
- Whether the inventions are likely to be separately patentable
For a more detailed explanation of how the USPTO determines independence and distinctness, you would need to refer to other sections of the MPEP, such as MPEP 803 and 806, which provide more specific guidance on this topic.
To learn more: