Can a plant be protected under both plant patent and utility patent provisions?
Yes, a plant can be protected under both plant patent (35 U.S.C. 161) and utility patent (35 U.S.C. 101) provisions. The MPEP cites the Supreme Court case J.E.M. Ag Supply, Inc. v. Pioneer Hi-Bred Int’l, Inc., which held that: “patentable subject matter under 35 U.S.C. 101 includes newly developed plants, even though plant protection is…
Read MoreHow does the written description requirement differ for plant patents compared to utility patents?
The written description requirement for plant patents is less stringent than for utility patents. This difference is rooted in the unique nature of plants and the historical challenges of describing them in patent applications. The MPEP cites the Supreme Court’s explanation in Diamond v. Chakrabarty: “In enacting the Plant Patent Act, Congress addressed both of…
Read MoreHow does claiming priority for a plant patent differ from utility patents?
Claiming priority for a plant patent is similar to claiming priority for a utility patent, but with some specific provisions tailored to plant-related inventions. The key difference lies in the type of foreign application that can serve as a basis for the priority claim. For plant patents, MPEP 1613 states: “Pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 119(f),…
Read MoreHow should the title of a plant patent be formulated?
The title of a plant patent should relate to the entire plant and not to its flower or fruit. According to MPEP 1610: “The title of the invention must relate to the entire plant and not to its flower or fruit, thus: Apple Tree, Rose Plant.” This guidance ensures that the title accurately represents the…
Read MoreIs there any exception to statutory requirements for plant patents?
Yes, there is one exception to the statutory requirements for plant patents. According to MPEP § 1608: The sole exception in terms of applicability of these statutory provisions is set forth in 35 U.S.C. 162. 35 U.S.C. 162 provides specific provisions for plant patents, including the description requirement for plant patent applications. This exception acknowledges…
Read MoreAre plant specimens required for plant patent applications?
Plant specimens are not automatically required for plant patent applications. However, as stated in MPEP 1607, “The applicant may be required to furnish specimens of the plant, or its flower or fruit, in a quantity and at a time in its stage of growth as may be designated, for study and inspection.” This means that…
Read MoreWhat types of content should be avoided in plant patent specifications?
When drafting a plant patent specification, certain types of content should be avoided. The MPEP 1610 provides guidance on this matter: Unwarranted advertising: “Care should also be exercised that the specification does not contain unwarranted advertising, for example, ‘the disclosed plant being grown in the XYZ Nurseries of Topeka, Kansas.’” Laudatory expressions: “Nor should the…
Read MoreWhat is the right of priority for plant patent applications based on plant breeder’s rights?
The right of priority for plant patent applications based on plant breeder’s rights is established under 35 U.S.C. 119(f). This provision allows an applicant for a plant patent to claim priority based on an earlier application for plant breeder’s rights filed in certain foreign countries. According to MPEP 1613: “Pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 119(f), an…
Read MoreHow do examiners conduct prior art searches for plant patent applications?
Examiners conduct prior art searches for plant patent applications using various resources. The MPEP § 1608 outlines the process: The prior art considered by the examiner is developed by a search of appropriate subclasses of the United States patent classification system as well as patent and nonpatent literature data bases. This comprehensive approach ensures that…
Read MoreWhat are the requirements for photographs in plant patent applications?
According to MPEP 1606, photographs are acceptable as drawings in plant patent applications and color drawings or photographs are generally required. The MPEP states: “Photographs and drawings must be clear, and of sufficient quality to show the plant or the characteristics that are the subject of the plant patent application.” Additionally: Black and white photographs…
Read More