Is an appeal to a U.S. District Court available in inter partes reexamination proceedings?

No, an appeal to a U.S. District Court is not available in inter partes reexamination proceedings. The MPEP 2683 clearly states: “The remedy by civil action under 35 U.S.C. 145 is not available to the patent owner and the third party requester in an inter partes reexamination proceeding. Patent owners and third party requesters dissatisfied…

Read More

How does the USPTO handle concurrent proceedings during ex parte reexamination?

The MPEP 2288 addresses the handling of concurrent proceedings during ex parte reexamination. It states: “If concurrent proceedings are pending at the time the ex parte reexamination certificate is to be issued, the USPTO may suspend the issuance of the certificate until the concurrent proceedings are terminated.” This means that if there are other ongoing…

Read More

Can a patent with prolix claims be invalidated after issuance?

Yes, a patent with prolix claims can potentially be invalidated after issuance, particularly on grounds of indefiniteness under 35 U.S.C. 112(b). While the MPEP 2173.05(m) guidance on prolix claims is primarily for examiners during prosecution, the underlying principle of claim clarity remains relevant post-issuance. In post-grant proceedings or litigation, if a court determines that the…

Read More

How does the broadest reasonable interpretation differ from the Phillips standard used in litigation?

The broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) standard used by the USPTO differs from the Phillips claim construction standard used in federal courts during patent litigation. MPEP 2111 acknowledges this difference: “The broadest reasonable interpretation does not mean the broadest possible interpretation. Rather, the meaning given to a claim term must be consistent with the ordinary and…

Read More

What is the role of the USPTO Solicitor in patent litigation?

The USPTO Solicitor plays a crucial role in patent litigation, particularly in cases involving the USPTO or appeals of USPTO decisions. Based on MPEP 1002.02(k)(3), the Solicitor’s responsibilities include: Deciding on petitions for extension of time in court matters related to 35 U.S.C. 142, 145, and 146 Handling petitions relating to ex parte questions in…

Read More