What is the “markedly different characteristics” analysis in patent examination?
The “markedly different characteristics” analysis is a key part of determining the patent eligibility of nature-based products. According to the MPEP Section 2106.04(b): “When a claim recites a nature-based product limitation, examiners should use the markedly different characteristics analysis discussed in MPEP § 2106.04(c) to evaluate the nature-based product limitation and determine the answer to…
Read MoreHow does the ‘markedly different characteristics’ analysis relate to nature-based products?
The ‘markedly different characteristics’ analysis is used to determine whether a nature-based product is a ‘product of nature’ exception. However, according to MPEP 2106.06(a), this analysis is not always necessary: “A claim that recites a nature-based product, but clearly does not attempt to tie up the nature-based product, does not require a markedly different characteristics…
Read MoreWhat are some examples of products that have been found to have or lack markedly different characteristics?
The MPEP provides several examples of products that have been found to have or lack markedly different characteristics from their natural counterparts. These examples are based on court decisions and help illustrate the application of the analysis. Products found to have markedly different characteristics: Chakrabarty’s genetically modified bacterium: “This bacterium had a changed functional characteristic,…
Read MoreHow do you determine if a characteristic is “markedly different”?
Determining whether a characteristic is “markedly different” is a critical part of the analysis for patent eligibility of nature-based products. The MPEP provides guidance on this evaluation: “The courts have emphasized that to show a marked difference, a characteristic must be changed as compared to nature, and cannot be an inherent or innate characteristic of…
Read MoreWhat types of characteristics are considered in the markedly different characteristics analysis?
The markedly different characteristics analysis considers various types of characteristics when comparing a claimed nature-based product to its naturally occurring counterpart. According to MPEP 2106.04(c), these characteristics can include, but are not limited to: Chemical properties Physical properties Functional properties Structure and form Biological or pharmacological properties The MPEP provides guidance on this analysis: “Markedly…
Read MoreHow does the broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) affect the examination of nature-based product claims?
The broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) plays a crucial role in the examination of nature-based product claims. The MPEP Section 2106.04(b) explains: “It is important to keep in mind that under the broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) of the claims, a nature-based product limitation may encompass both eligible and ineligible products.” Key points to understand: A claim…
Read More