+1.970.776.4355 · Loveland, CO · Russ Krajec, principal Currently accepting Fractional Chief IP Officer engagements →

Inventorship Is About Human Psychology, Not Legal Doctrine

Patent lawyers explain inventorship as a legal rule. A joint inventor needs to contribute at least one limitation to at least one claim.[1] If the claims change during prosecution, inventorship may need to be revisited.[2] Add a limitation, and maybe you add an inventor. Delete a limitation, and maybe you remove one.

Patent lawyers explain inventorship as a legal rule. A joint inventor needs to contribute at least one limitation to at least one claim.[1] If the claims change during prosecution, inventorship may need to be revisited.[2] Add a limitation, and maybe you add an inventor. Delete a limitation, and maybe you remove one.

The practical risk of inventorship is human psychology.

Inventorship creates a large surface area for attack on a patent. If I am defending against a patent infringement claim, and your patent has several inventors, I am going to look for the weakest link. I am going to call every inventor I can find, especially the one who left the company years ago, the one who feels burned, the one who did not get enough stock, the one who thinks someone else got too much credit, or the one who has regrets about how things ended. I do not need every inventor to cooperate. I only need one of them to start talking.[3]

Once that happens, the problem is no longer whether my product infringes your patent. The fight becomes whether your patent is valid at all.

All I need is one former inventor to say, “That person did not invent anything,” or, “I came up with the real idea,” or, “Those names should never have been on the patent.” Whether that statement is true, half true, self-serving, or distorted by time does not matter at first. The statement creates a dispute, which gives the defendant a reason to attack inventorship and forces the patent owner to defend it.

If the defendant can turn the case into an inventorship fight, the patent owner has to spend more money, time, and energy to keep the patent alive long enough to reach the infringement dispute. Even if the defendant loses the inventorship argument, the defendant gains delay, leverage, cost, and uncertainty. The patent starts to look weaker, settlement becomes harder, and enforcement costs more.

If the inventorship problem looks serious enough, the enforcement action can collapse before it reaches the infringement issues.

A legal framework governs inventorship and attaches defined consequences to errors.[4] The strict legal definition does not decide the outcome in practice. Someone with an axe to grind only has to assert that there is an inventorship problem. That assertion can derail the patent owner’s rights, whether or not it is right.[5]

Once inventorship becomes part of the fight, the patent owner is pulled into a credibility contest that may have nothing to do with the invention or the accused infringer’s conduct. The owner has to prove historical facts through human memory, which is weak, inconsistent, and emotional.

Two inventors will not remember an invention meeting the same way fifteen years later. Executives will not remember who contributed what with the same clarity. A former employee with an axe to grind will not tell the story neutrally.

An Inventorship Dispute Opens Your Private Records

When inventorship is tight and uncontested, the history of how the invention came about never arises. Nobody asks who was in the room or what was said, and the record behind the patent stays private.

A question about inventorship changes that. When an inventor is added to an application, or someone challenges who belongs on the patent, the other side has a reason to ask how the invention was made, and a reason to ask for records they would never otherwise see.

They ask who attended the invention meetings and what was discussed. They ask what your attorney said at the time. They ask to see the invention notebooks, then the rest of the paper trail around those dates. Each answer names more people and more documents, so each request leads to the next.

Your own people are pulled in as well. The inventors, the engineers who attended the meetings, and the executives who made the call all have to explain what happened, years later, to a lawyer who is looking for a gap in the story.

This is separate from the credibility fight. The credibility fight is about who the jury believes. The records fight is about how much of your private history the other side gets to read before the case reaches the question you came to answer.

A clean inventorship record keeps those records private. A disputed one opens them, and the patent owner pays in time, money, and disruption for every document.

Naming Too Many Inventors Creates Risk

When I see patents with six, eight, or twelve inventors, I see enforcement risk. The patent may be technically valid, have strong claims, and cover an important product, but the number of inventors makes it harder to trust.

One of the worst behaviors I see is adding too many inventors to a patent.[6]

This usually happens for emotional or political reasons. A team works together, management wants harmony, and somebody decides that everybody contributed, so everybody should be named. It feels inclusive and fair, avoids awkward conversations, and keeps people happy in the short term.

The more names on a patent, the more potential witnesses, the more conflicting memories, and the more future resentment built into the file.

An inventor who has no obligation to assign has ownership rights in the patent. Every name on the list is a possible owner, and every disputed name is a possible ownership fight.[7]

People may not complain while they are still at the company and getting paid. They may not object when the application is submitted, or understand the consequences at the time. Resentment does not disappear, though. When someone leaves the company, gets overlooked, feels disrespected, or watches the company succeed without them, it can surface at the worst moment.

At that point the patent owner is dealing with wounded pride, which is dangerous evidence.

Each additional inventor adds an attack point and raises the odds that one person eventually says something unhelpful. That weakens the patent in practice before any litigation begins.

Continuations Make the Problem Worse

Continuation applications increase inventorship risk.

I have seen a company submit the original patent applications with one set of inventors, then later submit continuations that added several more inventors. The patent attorneys said nothing. They followed instructions and prepared the papers. Legally, maybe there was an argument for it.[8] Maybe there was documentation, and maybe somebody could defend the change.

How the change looks matters more than the legal argument for it.

If I am attacking that patent family, I will look at those continuations and ask the obvious questions. Why were these people not inventors at the beginning? Why did they only appear later? What changed? Were they really inventors, or were they added to placate someone? If they were true inventors, why were they omitted from the first application? If they were not true inventors, why were they added later?

Even a good explanation means there is now something to explain. Enforcement works best when the story is simple and credible, and a complicated story about changing inventorship across a continuation chain already costs credibility.

I have also seen the reverse: a patent family starts with multiple inventors, then a later continuation names only the CEO as the inventor. Maybe that is legally correct, because the claims were rewritten and now reflect only what the CEO contributed. To the other inventors, it looks like the CEO removed them.

That perception creates anger, suspicion, and a sense of personal theft. Inventorship is one of the few recognitions in business that feels permanent, and people attach their identity to it. Many believe it will outlive them, and many expect it to be read at their funeral.

When you add people too casually, you cheapen it. When you remove people later, you inflame it.

Both mistakes create future witnesses for the other side.

Someone added later who really is an inventor, and who has no obligation to assign, has ownership rights. The other side gains a possible owner as well as a witness.

Inventorship Used as Extortion

Some inventorship problems are planted on purpose.

I met an “inventor” who milled around a local makerspace. The makerspace had 3D printers, woodworking equipment, metal and welding equipment, and every tool you could imagine. It was a beehive of activity for people working on their ideas.

This “inventor” would go around to everyone and “offer suggestions.” He would appear to be good hearted and helpful, often spending a great deal of time with the entrepreneur building their project.[9]

The “inventor” told me that he did this specifically so that when the entrepreneur made it big, he would claim ownership as a co-inventor.

He knew that inventorship was a very powerful weapon that he could use to extort money from an entrepreneur as soon as that entrepreneur started getting some success.[10]

The weapon was ownership. An added inventor who has no obligation to assign has ownership rights in the patent. Those ownership rights were what the “inventor” planned to sell back to the entrepreneur.

It does not matter whether he was an inventor. His plan was to litigate that he was left off the patent and should be entitled to the profit.

Would he win?

Does it matter? No.

The damage is done. The entrepreneur is forced to either spend a bunch of money in patent litigation or just pay off the “inventor.”[11]

Nothing in that plan required a lie at the start. Every conversation was friendly, and every suggestion looked like help. The demand would come later, when there was money to ask for and the entrepreneur had the most to lose.

He did not need it to work right away. Inventorship is a long-term item, and a question about who belongs on a patent can surface a decade or so after the work was done.

A former inventor with a grievance becomes a witness by accident. This man made himself a future witness on purpose.

Once he raises the question, the earlier sections apply. The entrepreneur has to answer for the meetings, the notebooks, and the conversations, and has to spend the time and money to do it while the business is growing.

His story is one example of how unmanaged inventorship can cripple a company years after the decisions that caused it.

What Inventorship Means to Inventors

A technically legal inventorship decision still has to survive the people involved. They have to accept it years later, when the stakes are higher and the relationships are broken.

Inventorship matters deeply to inventors. It is one of the highest forms of professional recognition many people will ever receive.[12] Changing the names on a patent, even in technically defensible ways, changes how people understand their own contribution, status, legacy, and identity.

The patent owner may think the paperwork is in order, and the attorneys may think the record is good enough. The emotional damage may already be done, and when enforcement begins, those emotions can be used against the owner.

The cleanest patents are legally correct and leave little room for future resentment.

The Best Practice Is to Name Few Inventors

Many people respond to inventorship risk with better documentation: map each inventor to specific claim limitations and preserve records of who contributed what. That is sensible, and it helps less than people expect.

Documentation has value only when someone who understands what it must prove in litigation creates it at the time. An engineer’s meeting notes differ from a structured inventorship record made by someone with enforcement experience. Most documentation was never designed to withstand cross-examination. It ages poorly, becomes incomplete, or stops matching the claims that matter as continuations reshape the family.

The most reliable solution is simpler: name as few inventors as possible.

Every additional inventor creates another attack surface, another personality, another memory, another relationship that can sour, and another future witness who can cause damage.

Fewer inventors mean fewer credibility battles, fewer people whose stories must align years later, fewer opportunities for the defendant to manufacture uncertainty, and fewer reasons for the other side to ask for your invention notebooks, your meeting records, and what your attorney said at the time.

Enforceable patents need narrow, disciplined, intentional inventorship.

Who Enforces This Discipline

The attorney will not enforce it. The attorney follows instructions. If management says “add these three people,” the attorney prepares the papers. The attorney has little reason to push back on inventorship decisions and little visibility into the human dynamics inside the company.

The CTO and the CEO will not either. Both want short-term harmony and peace, which is a reasonable thing to want, and naming everyone as an inventor avoids difficult conversations. The CTO is often the person most likely to expand inventorship for political reasons.

Someone inside the company must own inventorship decisions with enforcement consequences in mind. That person needs to understand what inventorship looks like under cross-examination ten years from now, which can differ from how it feels in a team meeting today.

That is a CIPO function.

The CIPO is responsible for reducing inventorship risk. The CEO and the CTO want short-term harmony and peace, and a CIPO can take the fall for being the “bad guy.” The CIPO enforces strict limits on the inventorship list, so the CEO and the CTO do not have to deliver that message to their own people.[13]

Stop Treating Inventorship Casually

Inventorship is often handled as an administrative detail, but it is one of the most important structural decisions in a patent program.

It affects enforceability, valuation, litigation cost, and settlement leverage. Done poorly, inventorship can damage a patent long before anyone tries to enforce it, and done carelessly it can turn a strong patent into an expensive distraction.

Inventorship controls the future risk created by people who will remember events differently, feel credit differently, and react to success differently. The law matters, and the psychology matters more.

Name as few inventors as possible. Do not use inventorship to reward participation or to keep peace on a team. Do not use continuations to reshuffle names for political convenience. Legal correctness today does not prevent human conflict tomorrow.


Sources


1 The MPEP states the test as a contribution to the conception of the claimed invention, and states that joint inventors need not each contribute to every claim. See MPEP § 2109, Inventorship and MPEP § 2109.01, Joint Inventorship. The Federal Circuit applies the same rule: “All inventors, even those who contribute to only one claim or one aspect of one claim of a patent, must be listed on that patent.” Vapor Point LLC v. Moorhead, 832 F.3d 1343 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (appeal No. 2015-1801, decided August 10, 2016). The one-limitation shorthand appears in two earlier BlueIron posts: Patent Ethics: Is it Ethical for the Patent Attorney to list themselves as an inventor? and Stolen Valor: How Sleazy Patent Attorneys Abuse Inventorship. ↩

2 A request under 37 CFR 1.48 corrects inventorship in an application. See MPEP § 602.01(c)(1), Correction of Inventorship in an Application and 37 CFR § 1.48. ↩

3 Patent Ethics: Is it Ethical for the Patent Attorney to list themselves as an inventor? describes the same pattern: an inventor who has left the company and still holds a grudge is called during litigation. ↩

4 MPEP § 2157, Improper Naming of Inventors lists three routes: a derivation proceeding under 35 U.S.C. 135, a correction under 37 CFR 1.48, or a rejection under 35 U.S.C. 101 and 115. See also 35 U.S.C. § 256, Correction of named inventor and Damage Control: Filing Patents After An Employee Leaves, which describes improper inventorship as the easiest way to invalidate a patent. ↩

5 Primary text of 35 U.S.C. § 256 (govinfo, United States Code 2023 edition): the error of omitting inventors or naming persons who are not inventors “shall not invalidate the patent in which such error occurred if it can be corrected as provided in this section.” The text also notes that Pub. L. 112-29 (September 16, 2011) struck the words “and such error arose without any deceptive intention on his part” from § 256(a). 35 U.S.C. § 116(c) was amended the same way. On the merits the statute favors the patent owner. The risk this post describes is the cost and disruption of answering an assertion, which the statute does not remove. ↩

6 BlueIron’s earlier post Lots of inventors means lots of problems covers the same ground: managers hand out inventorship as a bonus, the resentment that results, and the practice of having each inventor initial the limitations they contributed. ↩

7 Under 35 U.S.C. § 261, an assignment of a patent or any interest in it must be in writing. Under 35 U.S.C. § 262, absent an agreement to the contrary, each joint owner of a patent may make, use, offer to sell, or sell the invention in the United States “without the consent of and without accounting to the other owners.” In Vapor Point LLC v. Moorhead the opinion recounts the argument, citing Enovsys, that a joint owner must join all co-owners to sue, and the concurrence records that the company conceded it had no executed written assignment from the people added as inventors. The ownership point applies to a person who really is an inventor. Vapor Point separates inventorship, who actually invented the claimed subject matter, from ownership, who holds legal title. ↩

8 An application that claims the benefit of an earlier application must name at least one inventor from the earlier application, so the list of inventors can differ between a parent and a continuation. See MPEP § 2109, Inventorship and MPEP § 602.01(c)(1). ↩

9 The MPEP states that conception is required for inventorship, and that suggesting a desired result without the means of reaching it does not make someone a coinventor. See MPEP § 2109, Inventorship. BlueIron’s earlier post Lots of inventors means lots of problems makes the same point about the person who blurts out a suggestion in a meeting. ↩

10 What an IP-Backed Lender Sees That You Missed describes a related pattern: an inventor never properly identified as a co-inventor who now claims the entire patent, and inventors who withhold assignments as leverage, which that post calls patent blackmail. Using Patents as Blackmail covers a case where the company obtained an invention assignment and a non-compete from a former CTO before he wrote the patents he had planned. ↩

11 In Vapor Point LLC v. Moorhead, two people who had not been named sued under 35 U.S.C. § 256 to be added as inventors on a company’s patents. After a four-day evidentiary hearing the district court added them, dismissed the company’s infringement claim against them with prejudice, and the Federal Circuit affirmed. The company had not joined the new co-inventors in its suit and had no written assignment from them. BlueIron’s Strategic Partnerships are often Neither discusses the case. ↩

12 Stolen Valor: How Sleazy Patent Attorneys Abuse Inventorship covers what being named as an inventor means to an innovator, and Lots of inventors means lots of problems makes the same point about the funeral. ↩

13 Your Inventor Loves Your Patent Attorney. That Is the Problem. describes how an inventor defends a relationship and resents the messenger who questions it, and sets out the CIPO’s role as an independent evaluator who works before the outside attorney does. That post does not discuss inventorship. ↩

Investing in Patents — book cover by Russ Krajec
The book

Patents that work as assets — not paperwork.

Why most patents are worthless. Why your attorney’s incentives don’t align with yours. And the decision framework that separates investment-grade patents from expensive paperwork.

Free online · or order a copy