When does an examiner decide to hold an appeal conference?
An examiner decides to hold an appeal conference when they believe the appeal should proceed and an examiner’s answer should be prepared. MPEP 2676 states: “If the examiner reaches the conclusion that the appeal should go forward and an examiner’s answer should be prepared, the examiner will arrange … for an appeal conference to be…
Read MoreWhat is an appeal conference in inter partes reexamination?
An appeal conference in inter partes reexamination is a procedure conducted when an examiner believes an appeal should go forward and an examiner’s answer should be prepared. According to MPEP 2676, “If the examiner reaches the conclusion that the appeal should go forward and an examiner’s answer should be prepared, the examiner will arrange (via…
Read MoreCan an examiner avoid an appeal conference?
Yes, an examiner can avoid an appeal conference under certain circumstances. The MPEP 1207.01 states: “However, if the examiner charged with the responsibility of preparing the examiner’s answer reaches a conclusion that the appeal should not go forward and the supervisory patent examiner (SPE) approves, then no appeal conference is necessary.” In such cases, the…
Read MoreHow is an appeal conference documented in the examiner’s answer?
The appeal conference must be documented in the examiner’s answer to ensure a clear record. The MPEP 1207.01 provides specific instructions: “On the examiner’s answer, below the primary examiner’s signature, the word “Conferees:” should be included, followed by the typed or printed names of the other two appeal conference participants. These two appeal conference participants…
Read MoreWhat should be considered during an appeal conference?
During an appeal conference, examiners should consider several aspects of the case. According to MPEP 1207.01: “During the appeal conference, consideration should be given to the possibility of dropping cumulative art rejections and eliminating technical rejections of doubtful value.” The main points to consider include: The merits of the issues on appeal Possibility of dropping…
Read MoreWhat is an appeal conference in patent examination?
An appeal conference is a mandatory process in patent examination when an acceptable brief has been filed. According to MPEP 1207.01, An appeal conference is mandatory in all cases in which an acceptable brief ( MPEP § 1205 ) has been filed. The purpose of this conference is to review the merits of the issues…
Read More