When can an examiner not require restriction between species in a patent application?
An examiner cannot require restriction between species in a patent application under certain circumstances. The MPEP 808.01(a) provides guidance on this:
“In applications where only generic claims are presented, restriction cannot be required unless the generic claims recite or encompass such a multiplicity of species that an unduly extensive and burdensome search would be necessary to search the entire scope of the claim.”
Based on this, an examiner cannot require restriction between species when:
- Only generic claims are present in the application
- The number of species encompassed by the generic claims is not excessive
- Searching the entire scope of the generic claims would not be unduly burdensome
- The species are not mutually exclusive or patentably distinct
It’s important for applicants to understand these conditions to effectively respond to or potentially challenge improper species requirements.
To learn more: