Can an applicant challenge a restriction requirement in a patent application?
Yes, an applicant can challenge a restriction requirement in a patent application. While MPEP 808 outlines the reasons for insisting upon restriction, applicants have the right to respond to and potentially overcome these requirements. Here’s how:
- File a response arguing against the restriction requirement
- Demonstrate that the inventions are not independent or distinct
- Show that there would not be a serious search or examination burden
- Request reconsideration of the requirement
The MPEP states that examiners must provide “the reasons (as distinguished from the mere statement of conclusion) why each invention as claimed is either independent or distinct from the other(s)“. If an applicant believes these reasons are insufficient or incorrect, they can challenge the requirement by providing counterarguments and evidence.
If the examiner maintains the restriction after reconsideration, the applicant can file a petition to the Director under 37 CFR 1.144 for further review.
To learn more: