What happens if an International Searching Authority finds a lack of unity of invention?
If an International Searching Authority (ISA) determines that an international application does not comply with the requirement of unity of invention, it may request additional fees from the applicant. According to MPEP 1840: “If the selected ISA considers that the international application does not comply with the requirement of unity of invention as set forth…
Read MoreHow does the ISA determine if unity of invention exists a priori?
How does the ISA determine if unity of invention exists a priori? The International Searching Authority (ISA) determines unity of invention a priori by examining the claims before considering the prior art. According to MPEP 1850: “Lack of unity of invention may be directly evident ‘a priori,’ that is, before considering the claims in relation…
Read MoreHow does the International Preliminary Examining Authority handle lack of unity of invention?
When the International Preliminary Examining Authority (IPEA) finds a lack of unity of invention, they typically follow these steps: Prepare and send an invitation to the applicant using Form PCT/IPEA/405 Request payment of additional fees or restriction of claims Identify the “main invention” to be examined if no additional fees are paid or restrictions made…
Read MoreHow does the Director of International Patent Legal Administration handle issues with international preliminary examination?
The Director of International Patent Legal Administration plays a crucial role in addressing issues related to international preliminary examination. Their responsibilities include: Deciding petitions to review the holding of lack of unity of invention in international applications Deciding petitions to review the refusal to enter the national stage in international applications MPEP 1002.02(p) states: “The…
Read MoreWhat is Form PCT/IPEA/405 and when is it used?
Form PCT/IPEA/405, also known as the “Invitation to restrict or pay additional fees,” is used in the international patent examination process. It is issued when an examiner determines that an international application lacks unity of invention. According to MPEP 1875.01, this form is used to “invite the applicant, at his/her option, to restrict the claims…
Read MoreWhat information must be included in Form PCT/IPEA/405?
Form PCT/IPEA/405 must include several key pieces of information as outlined in MPEP 1875.01: Reasons for lack of unity: “The examiner must also explain the reasons why the international application is not considered to comply with the requirement of unity of invention.“ Compliant claim groups: “The examiner must also specify, on Form PCT/IPEA/405, at least…
Read MoreWhat options does an examiner have when unity of invention is lacking?
When an examiner at the International Preliminary Examining Authority (IPEA) determines that unity of invention is lacking, they have two main options: Invite the applicant to restrict the claims or pay additional examination fees. Choose not to invite the applicant and proceed with the examination. MPEP 1875 states: “There are cases of lack of unity…
Read MoreHow does an examiner determine lack of unity in a national stage application?
When determining lack of unity in a national stage application, an examiner must follow specific steps as outlined in MPEP 1893.03(d): List the different groups of claims Explain why each group lacks unity with each other group Specifically describe the unique special technical feature in each group The MPEP states: “When making a unity of…
Read MoreHow does an examiner determine if an application lacks unity of invention?
An examiner determines if an application lacks unity of invention by assessing whether the claims are directed to a single general inventive concept. The MPEP 1875.01 provides guidance on this process: “The examiner must also specify, on Form PCT/IPEA/405, at least one group or groups of claims which, if elected, would comply with the requirement…
Read MoreWhat happens if an applicant doesn’t respond to a lack of unity invitation?
If an applicant fails to respond to an invitation to restrict claims or pay additional fees due to lack of unity of invention, the International Preliminary Examining Authority (IPEA) will proceed as follows: According to MPEP 1875, “The written opinion, if any, and international preliminary examination report must be established on the claims directed to…
Read More