How does the USPTO evaluate rebuttal evidence for obviousness rejections?
The USPTO evaluates rebuttal evidence for obviousness rejections by considering all relevant evidence and weighing it appropriately. As stated in MPEP 2145: “Office personnel should not evaluate rebuttal evidence for its ‘knockdown’ value against the prima facie case, Piasecki, 745 F.2d at 1473, 223 USPQ at 788, or summarily dismiss it as not compelling or…
Read MoreWhat is the ‘teaching away’ doctrine in patent law?
The ‘teaching away’ doctrine is an important concept in patent law related to obviousness rejections. A prior art reference is said to ‘teach away’ from the claimed invention if it criticizes, discredits, or otherwise discourages the solution claimed. However, as MPEP 2145 explains: “A prior art reference that ‘teaches away’ from the claimed invention is…
Read MoreWhat is the burden of proof in rebutting a prima facie case of obviousness?
According to MPEP 2145, if a prima facie case of obviousness is established, the burden shifts to the applicant to come forward with arguments and/or evidence to rebut the prima facie case. As stated in the MPEP: “If a prima facie case of obviousness is established, the burden shifts to the applicant to come forward…
Read MoreWhat types of evidence can be used to rebut an obviousness rejection?
The MPEP outlines several types of evidence that can be used to rebut an obviousness rejection: Evidence of unexpected results Evidence that the claimed invention yields unexpectedly improved properties or properties not present in the prior art Evidence that the claimed invention was copied by others Evidence of the state of the art, the level…
Read MoreHow does the USPTO handle arguments about improper hindsight in obviousness rejections?
Applicants often argue that an examiner’s obviousness rejection is based on improper hindsight reasoning. MPEP 2145 addresses this issue: “Applicants may argue that the examiner’s conclusion of obviousness is based on improper hindsight reasoning. However, ‘[a]ny judgment on obviousness is in a sense necessarily a reconstruction based on hindsight reasoning, but so long as it…
Read More