What is the “on sale” bar in patent law and how does experimental use affect it?
The “on sale” bar in patent law is a provision that can prevent an inventor from obtaining a patent if their invention was on sale more than one year before the filing date of the patent application. However, experimental use can provide an exception to this bar. According to MPEP 2133.03(e): “If the use or…
Read MoreHow do courts weigh objective evidence against inventor testimony?
Courts typically give more weight to objective evidence than to inventor testimony when determining whether a use or sale was experimental. The MPEP 2133.03(e)(2) cites a recent case: “Sunoco Partners Mktg. & Terminals LP v. U.S. Venture, Inc., 32 F.4th 1161, 1171-72, 2022 USPQ2d 417 (Fed. Cir. 2022) (The Federal Circuit relied on the objective…
Read MoreWhat constitutes objective evidence of experimental use?
Objective evidence of experimental use typically includes documentation and actions that demonstrate the inventor’s intent to experiment rather than commercialize the invention. While the MPEP 2133.03(e)(2) doesn’t provide an exhaustive list, it suggests that such evidence may include: Informing customers about the experimental nature of the product or process Maintaining control over the invention during…
Read MoreWhat are the key factors in proving experimental use?
According to the MPEP and relevant case law, the key factors in proving experimental use are: Inventor Control: The extent of supervision and control maintained by the inventor over the invention during the alleged period of experimentation. Customer Awareness: The level of awareness customers or third parties have about the experimental nature of the use.…
Read MoreHow does inventor intent affect experimental use in patent law?
Inventor intent is crucial in determining whether an activity qualifies as experimental use. However, subjective intent alone is not sufficient. The MPEP states: “When sales are made in an ordinary commercial environment and the goods are placed outside the inventor’s control, an inventor’s secretly held subjective intent to ‘experiment,’ even if true, is unavailing without…
Read MoreWhat is the significance of intent in determining public use or on-sale bar?
The intent of the inventor is not sufficient alone to determine whether a public use or on-sale bar applies. As stated in MPEP 2133.03(e)(2): “When sales are made in an ordinary commercial environment and the goods are placed outside the inventor’s control, an inventor’s secretly held subjective intent to ‘experiment,’ even if true, is unavailing…
Read MoreWhat are the key factors in determining if an activity qualifies as experimental use?
What are the key factors in determining if an activity qualifies as experimental use? Determining whether an activity qualifies as experimental use involves considering several factors. According to MPEP 2133.03(e), key factors include: The nature of the activity The length of the test period Whether payment was made for the device Whether there was a…
Read MoreHow does experimental use affect public use in patent law?
Experimental use can negate what would otherwise be considered a public use in patent law. The MPEP 2133.03(e) states: “The use of an invention by the inventor himself, or of any other person under his direction, by way of experiment, and in order to bring the invention to perfection, has never been regarded as [a…
Read MoreHow does experimental use affect the public use bar in patent law?
Experimental use is an important exception to the public use bar in patent law. According to MPEP 2133.03(e): “The use of an invention by the inventor himself, or of any other person under his direction, by way of experiment, and in order to bring the invention to perfection, has never been regarded as [a public]…
Read MoreCan experimental use negate the on-sale bar?
While experimental use can potentially negate the on-sale bar, it becomes increasingly difficult to prove as commercial exploitation increases. The MPEP states: “As the degree of commercial exploitation in public use or sale activity increases, the burden on an applicant to establish clear and convincing evidence of experimental activity with respect to a public use…
Read More