What must a patent owner include in a supplemental examination request?
According to MPEP 2816.01, a patent owner must include specific information in a supplemental examination request: “[a] separate, detailed explanation of the relevance and manner of applying each item of information to each claim of the patent for which supplemental examination is requested.” This requirement is specified in 37 CFR 1.610(b)(5). If the patent owner…
Read MoreWhat claims are considered in a supplemental examination determination?
In a supplemental examination, the Office considers the claims of the patent that are in effect at the time of the determination. Specifically, “The claims of the patent in effect at the time of the determination will be the basis for deciding whether ‘a substantial new question of patentability’ (SNQ) is present.” (MPEP 2816.01) However,…
Read MoreWhat happens if a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ) is found during supplemental examination?
If a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ) is found during supplemental examination, the following occurs: Reexamination will be ordered under 35 U.S.C. 257. The Office may, at its discretion, reexamine claims other than those for which supplemental examination was originally requested. As stated in MPEP 2816.01: “If the examiner determines that a SNQ affecting…
Read MoreCan the examiner consider information beyond what the patent owner specified for each claim?
Yes, the examiner has discretion to consider information beyond what the patent owner specified for each claim in a supplemental examination request. According to MPEP 2816.01: “The examiner, however, has the discretion to determine whether any of the items of information properly submitted with the request raises a SNQ affecting any of the claims for…
Read MoreWhat happens if a patent owner doesn’t provide explanations for all requested claims?
If a patent owner fails to provide the required explanations for all requested claims in a supplemental examination, the following consequences apply: The patent owner is not entitled to supplemental examination of claims for which the required explanation was not provided. The Office will typically issue a notice of noncompliant supplemental examination request. As stated…
Read MoreAre amendments or new claims considered during supplemental examination?
No, amendments and new claims presented in copending post-patent Office proceedings are not considered during the supplemental examination process. According to MPEP 2816.01: “Amendments and/or new claims presented in any copending post-patent Office proceeding for the patent to be examined will not be considered nor commented upon when deciding a request for supplemental examination.” However,…
Read More