How does the USPTO handle protests filed against patent applications?
The USPTO has established procedures for reviewing protests to determine if they comply with 37 CFR 1.291 before being made of record in an application. Compliant protests are entered into the record and made available to the examiner for consideration as early as possible. According to the MPEP, “Evidence submitted in a protest will be…
Read MoreCan a protest be filed after a patent application has been published?
Yes, but with restrictions. According to MPEP 1901.06: “35 U.S.C. 122(c) permits the filing of a protest in an application after the application has been published if there is express written consent of the applicant.“ To file a protest after publication, the following conditions must be met: The protest must be accompanied by the written…
Read MoreWhat happens if a protest is non-compliant with USPTO regulations?
According to MPEP 1901.06, the treatment of non-compliant protests depends on the nature and extent of the non-compliance: Protests that fail to comply with 37 CFR 1.291(b) or (c) may not be entered. However, if the error is minor and does not raise ambiguity about the protest’s content, it may still be entered at the…
Read MoreHow does an examiner treat an entered protest during patent examination?
When a protest has been entered into the record of a patent application, the examiner must consider it during prosecution. According to MPEP 1901.06, the examiner must: Consider each prior art or other document submitted in conformance with 37 CFR 1.291(c) and any discussion of such documents in the protest. Consider any non-prior art issue(s)…
Read MoreCan an examiner require an applicant to respond to issues raised in a protest?
Yes, in certain circumstances, an examiner can require an applicant to respond to issues raised in a protest. According to MPEP 1901.06: “Where necessary or desirable to decide questions raised by the protest, under 37 CFR 1.291(f) the primary examiner can require the applicant to reply to the protest and answer specific questions raised by…
Read MoreCan an examiner communicate with a protestor regarding a filed protest?
No, examiners are not permitted to communicate with protestors regarding filed protests. The MPEP 1901.06 clearly states: “The examiner must not communicate with protestor in any way even if the protest is incomplete or the protestor inquires as to the status of any Office proceedings related to the protest.“ This prohibition applies regardless of the…
Read More